OSIJEK, Croatia, Aug 4 (IPS) - Every so often Dr. Zarko Domljan,
vice-president of the Croatian parliament, receives an unpleasant
letter protesting about the state of press freedom in Croatia --
be it from the Croatian independent media or human rights
watchdogs.
Reporters have learned that one such letter arrived on his desk
sent by the Council of Europe -- which promotes democracy and
respect for human rights in on the continent -- soon after the
Jun. 27 attacks against the satirical weekly newspaper
the 'Feral Tribune', published in the Croatian coastal town of Split.
There, on the main town square, a gang confiscated copies of the
'Feral Tribune' from newsboys and newsstands and publicly burned
them at several locations on the streets of Split.
This incident could not have occurred at a worse time for Croatia
as the newspapers were burned on the streets at the same time as
the PHARE -- a European Union development programme for central
and eastern Europe -- delegation was visiting Zagreb.
The embarrassment of the Split incident was enormous since the
PHARE Programme delegation had canceled a previously scheduled
visit. Indeed, concerns about Press freedoms in the former
Yugoslav republic was one of the main reasons for the postponement
of Croatia's membership of the PHARE Programme.
Domljan attributed the public burning to a freak ''group of
extremists who only wanted to express their political opinions,
that were different to that of the weekly.''
However, this is only one incident indicating a strategy towards
thwarting the freedom of the independent media in Croatia.
In the past, the 'Feral Tribune' editor was violently thrown out
of his office by the army due to the weekly's open and frank
reporting on the abuses of power by the Croatian government and
President Franjo Tudjman.
Later, it was burdened with a hefty tax -- normally only levied
on pornographic magazines. After numerous protests and pressure
from around the world, the tax was abolished.
Now, the latest strategy for its financial ruin is a wave of
libel cases filed privately, mainly by high government officials
demanding heavy damages.
Indeed, since the early days when unruly editors were thrown out
of their editorial offices at gun point, the Croatian authorities
have learned that there are more subtle and fruitful methods of
dealing with them.
The taxation ploy did not work, and it is yet to be determined
what gains will be made from the lawsuits. In the meanwhile, the
government is employing another strategy aimed not only at
underming the independent Press, but at trying to convince the
international community that the media scene is vibrant in
Croatia.
One high official in the Croatian government recently commented on the level of freedom of the media in Croatia by pointing at the
enormous number of publications. ''Just look at the newsstands,
there have never been so many different newspapers there!''
Whether intentionally or not, in these few words he expounded the
governments strategy for dealing with foreign enquiries about
media freedom in Croatia.
The reasoning behind such a philosophy is that in a country where
the newsstands are too crammed to hold the immense number of
publications on sale, there should be no doubt about the freedom
of the press.
Although the state already strictly controls the national
television and radio stations, as well as four of the five daily
newspapers in the country, in the last few months, there have been
a flood of new newspaper titles that have been started and
financed by the state.
They range from newspapers dedicated to demographic renewal to
satirical magazines aimed at competing with the 'Feral Tribune'.
'Obzor' (Horizon), 'Drzavnost' (Statehood), 'Velebit' (Mt.
Velebit), 'Narod' (People), 'Zora' (Dawn), 'Hrvatsko Slovo'
(Croatian Voice), and 'Zalac' (Sting) are some of the titles that
have appeared. The hope seems to be that their sheer numbers will
squeeze out the independent papers on the stands.
The circulation of all these papers is meagre, making it quite
obvious that they would quickly disappear if state financial
support dried out.
Apart from crowding out space on the Croatian newspaper market,
they also perform the role of creating the illusion of pluralist,
diverse journalism that is present in democratic societies.
Newspaper distribution in Croatia, including the largest network
of newsstands, is monopolised by ''Tisak'' the state-controlled
distributor. And it is hard not to infer that the 'state media'
are afforded the most prominent positions on the newsstands, no
matter how meagre their sales.
When such a sophisticated way of state control over the media is
added to the confiscation and even burning copies of the 'Feral
Tribune', one gets a very powerful and efficient means of
suppression.
After the burning of 'Feral Tribune', many newsstand vendors hid
their copies of the weekly out of fear. In the flood of state
newspapers, the gap was not even noticed.
Another role fulfilled by the newpapers is raising the level of
media noise by screaming hysterically from their front pages
against the alleged national betrayal and the 'Yugo-nostalgia' of
the independent media and journalists.
President Tudjman once said independent journalists had ''sold
themselves to the enemies''.
The frenzied campaign that state journalists conduct against
their independent colleagues has already taken the form of a real
media war on a par with the one that was conducted against
Serbia's independent journalists in Belgrade in the wake of
Serbian aggression.
The most drastic division made between state journalists and
independent journalists was made by the President himself at a
recent national awards ceremony when he handed out numerous
decorations to journalists from the state-controlled media, for
their part in the ''homeland war'' against the Croatian Serbs.
Some of the decorated journalists had barely spent an hour
reporting from the frontlines, while others were the foremost
advocates of the media war and campaigns of hate.
On the other hand, not one journalist from the independent media
was decorated, although some have spent months reporting from the
front lines.
And it was not a case of the president being economical with the
medals -- he allotted no less than nine decorations to himself!
The irony of it all was not lost on Viktor Ivancic, the 'Feral
Tribune editor who said the whole exercise was a farce. ''These
are very hard times for satire. Whatever we write, the state will
come up with something far funnier than us,'' he said.
CROATIA-MEDIA: Press Faces Subtle And Severe State Suppression
By Drago Hedl, 8/4/95